Trumpeting And Strokes: Is There A Link?

Playing the trumpet may cause a stroke, according to some sources. German researchers have identified a few cases where trumpet players have caused so much damage to the blood vessels in their brains that it resulted in a stroke. This is due to the pressure applied to the blood vessels as the player blows forcefully into the trumpet, affecting the vessels in the chest and neck. However, other sources claim that there is not enough data to confirm a direct link between trumpet playing and strokes. While there have been reports of trumpeters experiencing dizziness, blackouts, and even strokes while playing high notes, these incidents may be influenced by individual factors such as pre-existing health conditions or playing techniques.

Playing the trumpet can cause high blood pressure

The act of blowing forcefully into a trumpet increases the pressure on the chest and neck, affecting the blood vessels in the brain and causing them to rupture. This can lead to two types of strokes. The first type, accounting for 85% of cases, occurs when a blood clot blocks a vessel in the head, preventing adequate oxygen supply to the brain. The second type, responsible for 15% of cases, is when a blood vessel in the brain bursts, typically affecting younger individuals with weaker or improperly formed blood vessels.

Trumpet players often experience dizziness or blackouts when playing high notes due to the pressure required to produce those notes. This pressure causes a temporary collapse of the heart valves, leading to reduced blood flow to the brain. When the player stops blowing, the blood pressure rises rapidly, resulting in dizziness. According to Bache and Edenborough, this change in blood pressure and heart rate can also lead to more severe conditions, such as blood accumulation in the brain.

Additionally, trumpet players may be at risk of developing laryngoceles, fluid- or air-filled masses in the neck, due to the strain of blowing the instrument. While these formations rarely require surgery, they underscore the physical demands of playing the trumpet and the potential impact on the player's health.

It is important to note that the risk of stroke due to trumpet playing is relatively uncommon. Dr. Evers suggests that individuals with a predisposition to stroke or underlying weaknesses in their arteries may be at higher risk. However, the data is limited, and more research is needed to definitively conclude that trumpet playing is dangerous.

Trumpet players may suffer from dizziness or blackouts

This phenomenon is not unique to trumpet players, as it can occur with any activity that involves straining, such as coughing, defecating, lifting heavy loads, or labour. However, it is important for trumpet players to be aware of this potential risk and to take steps to minimise the chances of it occurring.

One way to reduce the risk of dizziness or blackouts is to learn to play the trumpet as efficiently as possible, using only the amount of air and energy that is absolutely necessary. It is also important to avoid pushing too hard when playing high notes, as this can increase the risk of a blackout.

In addition, trumpet players should be cautious about playing high notes if they have any pre-existing health conditions or risk factors for stroke. For example, young people may be more susceptible to stroke while playing the trumpet due to improperly formed or weak blood vessels.

While the risk of stroke from playing the trumpet is relatively low, it is important for players to be informed and take appropriate precautions to minimise the risk.

Trumpet playing can lead to ruptured lip muscles

Ruptured orbicularis oris muscles result in weakened lips that cannot play high notes. This condition may require surgical repair, or it can be treated with rest. Trumpet players should be aware of this risk and take precautions to avoid injury. It is important to properly align the mouth, tongue, jaw, and facial muscles while playing to reduce the chances of rupturing the lip muscles.

In addition to ruptured lip muscles, trumpet players may also experience other physical ailments, such as dizziness or blackouts when playing high notes. This is caused by a temporary collapse of the heart valves, leading to reduced blood flow to the brain. When the player stops blowing, the blood pressure rises rapidly, resulting in dizziness.

Furthermore, trumpet playing can lead to increased pressure in the thorax, which may cause air bubbles to enter the bloodstream. This can be particularly dangerous for young people with a patent foramen ovale, an opening between two chambers in the heart. These air bubbles can travel to the brain and block blood vessels, resulting in mini-strokes or transient ischemic attacks.

While trumpet playing can have certain physical risks, it is important to note that these instances are rare and may be preventable with proper technique and awareness.

There is a risk of blood vessel rupture in the brain

Playing the trumpet can cause a stroke due to the risk of blood vessel rupture in the brain. This risk arises from the amount of pressure applied to blood vessels as one blows into the trumpet, affecting the blood vessels in the brain and causing them to rupture.

Research by German scientists, including Dr. Stefan Evers of the University of Munster, has identified several cases where trumpet players suffered damage to blood vessels in the brain, resulting in a stroke. Dr. Evers attributes this to the pressure on the chest and neck when blowing into the trumpet, which can cause blood vessels in the brain to rupture.

The risk of blood vessel rupture is higher in younger people, as their blood vessels may not have formed properly or may be weaker compared to adults. This type of stroke, where a blood vessel in the brain bursts, accounts for 15% of all stroke cases and affects approximately 300 to 350 people under the age of 17 in the UK annually.

While trumpet playing can increase the risk of blood vessel rupture and stroke, it is important to note that stroke from playing an instrument is considered very unusual. Dr. Evers also noted that most of the identified cases had a predisposition to stroke or some form of weakness in the arteries.

To minimise the risk of stroke while playing the trumpet, it is recommended to adopt proper playing techniques, such as using only the necessary amount of air and energy, and avoiding excessive force or tension. Additionally, consulting a doctor and undergoing vascular screening can help identify any potential risk factors and ensure that blood pressure is well-managed.

Trumpet players may be at risk of mini-strokes

Playing the trumpet involves a lot of blowing, which can put a lot of pressure on the chest and neck. This pressure can affect blood vessels in the brain, causing them to rupture and potentially leading to a stroke. While strokes among trumpet players are rare, there have been a few cases of musicians suffering damage to blood vessels in the brain from playing wind instruments, with trumpets being the most common instrument.

German researchers have identified a few possible reasons why playing the trumpet may lead to strokes. Firstly, the amount of pressure applied to the blood vessels as the musician blows into the trumpet can cause them to rupture. This is more likely to occur in younger players as their blood vessels may not have formed properly or may be weaker compared to adults.

Additionally, playing high notes on the trumpet can cause dizziness or blackouts due to a temporary drop in blood pressure. When trumpeters stop blowing, the blood pressure rises quickly, resulting in dizziness. This rapid change in blood pressure may also lead to a more serious condition, such as the accumulation of blood in the brain.

Case Studies

A 17-year-old trumpet player experienced transient ischemic attacks, or mini-strokes, while playing the instrument. These attacks were caused by an opening between two chambers in the heart, known as a patent foramen ovale, which allowed air bubbles to pass into the bloodstream and block blood vessels in the brain. Another case involved a 49-year-old man who practiced blowing a Shofar (a ram's horn used in Jewish ceremonies) and subsequently suffered a small intracerebral hemorrhage.

Reducing the Risk of Mini-Strokes

While playing the trumpet may pose a risk for mini-strokes, there are ways to mitigate this risk. Trumpet players should learn to play efficiently, using only the necessary amount of air and energy. It is also important to avoid taking on too many demanding gigs and to maintain a healthy lifestyle with adequate sleep and a good diet. For those at higher risk, consulting a doctor and undergoing vascular screening can help identify any potential issues.

Frequently asked questions