Cocoa's Laxative Effect: Fact Or Fiction?

Cocoa has been linked to improved bowel movements, but the evidence is mixed. While some people report that cocoa helps relieve constipation, there is no solid research confirming a direct link between cocoa and constipation relief. However, cocoa does contain fibre and caffeine, which are known to have a laxative effect.

Cocoa husks can help with constipation

The fibre in cocoa promotes healthier bowel habits. A study in 2012 found that the regular addition of two servings of soluble cocoa products, providing 2.26 and 6.60 g of total non-starch polysaccharides per day, to a Spanish diet effectively increased fibre intake to recommended levels. The product with the higher fibre content also promoted healthier bowel habits, including a reduced time to have a bowel movement and an increase in the number of daily bowel movements.

Cocoa is also a good source of magnesium, which is useful to ward off constipation. In addition, cocoa contains caffeine, which can increase the rate of motility – the contraction of the muscles in the digestive tract that encourage bowel movements. However, consuming too much caffeine can lead to chronic diarrhoea.

Cocoa is a good source of magnesium

Cocoa powder and dark chocolate are good sources of magnesium, with 420 milligrams per cup and 65 milligrams per 1-ounce serving, respectively. However, it is important to note that normal cocoa powder and chocolate have been chemically processed, which reduces the amount of magnesium and other beneficial compounds. Therefore, it is best to consume raw organic cocoa products to get the full benefits.

In addition to magnesium, cocoa is also rich in antioxidants, iron, calcium, and mood-boosting neurotransmitters. It is also high in iron, copper, and manganese and contains prebiotic fiber that can help feed beneficial bacteria in the gut.

Consuming cocoa can have positive effects on bowel function and constipation. A study found that consuming two servings of soluble cocoa products per day increased fiber intake and improved bowel habits, with participants reporting more frequent bowel movements and less constipation.

Overall, cocoa is a good source of magnesium and can provide numerous health benefits when consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

Chocolate contains caffeine, which can have a laxative effect

Chocolate is not usually considered a laxative, but it may help with constipation due to its caffeine and fibre content.

Caffeine can increase the rate of motility, which is the contraction of the muscles in the digestive tract that encourage bowel movements. The darker the chocolate, the higher the caffeine level. For example, an ounce of dark chocolate with 70 to 85% cacao solids has 22.7 milligrams of caffeine. If you eat more than an ounce, you could experience a laxative effect.

Chocolate also contains fibre, which helps move food through the digestive tract. Fibre is crucial to preventing constipation and normalising bowel movements. The darker the chocolate, the more fibre it has. One ounce of chocolate with 70 to 80% cacao solids has 3 grams of fibre, which is likely not enough to have an immediate laxative effect. However, if you eat a whole 3.5-ounce bar, you'll get 11 grams of fibre in one sitting, which, along with the caffeine content, could act as a laxative.

It is important to note that while chocolate may have a laxative effect due to its caffeine and fibre content, there is no evidence that cocoa directly causes constipation.

Chocolate is rich in fibre

Cocoa fibre contains a minimum of 59% fibre and less than 5% fat. It can be used as a bulking agent in chocolate food and beverage products, replacing sugar by up to 45% while retaining the same sensory properties. This is particularly useful in helping to reduce the risk of chronic diseases such as diabetes and obesity.

Cocoa is a good source of insoluble dietary fibre, with a total dietary fibre content of over 60% of dry matter. This is much higher than the estimated intake in Western countries. The consumption of cocoa products can therefore help to increase fibre intake to recommended levels.

A 2012 study found that the regular addition of two servings of soluble cocoa products, containing 15.1% and 22% of non-starch polysaccharides, to a Spanish diet increased fibre intake to recommended levels. The product containing 22% of non-starch polysaccharides also promoted healthier bowel habits, increasing the number of daily bowel movements and reducing the time to have a bowel movement. The consumption of cocoa products did not lead to an increase in body weight.

A 2006 study found that cocoa fibre could be considered an excellent source of dietary fibre, mainly insoluble dietary fibre, and could be used as an ingredient in fibre-rich functional foods.

Chocolate may cause constipation in people with IBS

Chocolate is a beloved treat, often given as gifts to loved ones and baked into cookies. However, for some people, chocolate may cause constipation. While studies have not confirmed a direct link between chocolate and constipation, many people claim to experience digestive issues after consuming it. This is especially true for those with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).

So, why does chocolate cause constipation in people with IBS? Let's explore the potential reasons and discuss ways to manage this issue.

The Link Between Chocolate and Constipation in IBS

The exact reason why chocolate triggers constipation in people with IBS is not entirely clear. However, it is known that IBS is associated with abnormalities in how the gut senses and reacts to food, bacteria, and other components in the "luminal microenvironment." This space inside the intestines and colon interacts with the immune system and nerves in the gut wall. As a result, what we eat can significantly impact gut function and sensation, leading to symptoms such as pain, cramping, bloating, and diarrhea.

Chocolate, especially milk chocolate, contains sugar (including lactose), milk proteins, and fat, which can trigger gut symptoms in susceptible individuals. These ingredients may influence gut function and sensation, causing constipation in some people with IBS.

Managing Constipation Caused by Chocolate

If you have IBS and find that chocolate triggers your constipation, there are a few things you can do:

• Moderation: Most people can tolerate small amounts of chocolate without issues. However, if you have IBS, it's best to limit your intake to avoid triggering symptoms.
• Alternatives: Consider carob, a brown, floury powder used as a chocolate substitute, or opt for yogurt-covered nuts or fruits.
• Avoid "Sugar-Free" Candies: Candies labeled as "sugar-free" often contain sorbitol or sucralose, which can trigger GI symptoms in people with IBS and other GI conditions.
• Increase Fiber and Water Intake: Constipation can be prevented by increasing your fiber and water intake. Aim for 22 to 34 grams of fiber per day and ensure you stay hydrated.
• Try Laxatives: If lifestyle changes don't help, over-the-counter laxatives can provide relief. Bulk-forming agents like Citrucel and Metamucil are options, but be sure to consult your doctor or pharmacist first.
• Eliminate Chocolate: If chocolate is a consistent trigger, try eliminating it from your diet for a while. If your constipation improves, you can slowly reintroduce small amounts of chocolate and monitor your symptoms.

The Dual Nature of Cocoa

Interestingly, while chocolate can cause constipation in some individuals, cocoa or its components may have the opposite effect. Cocoa husks, which are high in fiber, have been found to help relieve constipation in children. Additionally, research suggests that cocoa may promote the growth of beneficial gut bacteria.

In conclusion, while chocolate may cause constipation in people with IBS, the impact of cocoa itself is less clear and may even offer some digestive benefits. Further research is needed to fully understand the relationship between chocolate, cocoa, and gut health.

Frequently asked questions