Beer Belly Blues: The Diuretic Or Laxative Debate

Beer is a diuretic, which means drinking it will make you urinate more. This is because alcohol increases urine output. As a result, drinking beer can be dehydrating, especially if consumed in large quantities. However, the dehydrating effects of beer depend on its alcohol content. Beers with higher alcohol content are more dehydrating than those with lower alcohol content. In addition, the body's hydration status also influences the diuretic action of alcohol. When the body is hypohydrated, the diuretic effect of alcohol is reduced.

Beer is a diuretic, meaning it increases urine output

The diuretic effect of beer is due to its alcohol content. Alcohol increases urine output, which can lead to dehydration if you're not careful. This is because when you're drinking beer, you're peeing out more than you're taking in. The higher the alcohol content, the more diuretic the drink. For example, a study found that stronger alcoholic drinks like wine and spirits have a short-term diuretic effect, whereas weaker alcoholic drinks like beer do not. Interestingly, the same study found that urine output after drinking a typical beer was no different from that of a non-alcoholic beer or water.

Several other studies have come to similar conclusions: beer might actually hydrate us adequately! However, stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating, and drinks containing essential electrolytes are still better for hydration.

The diuretic effect of alcohol is thought to be caused by its suppression of the hormone vasopressin, or ADH. Vasopressin is usually released by the posterior pituitary gland in response to a fall in blood volume or a rise in plasma osmolality, and acts to conserve water. However, alcohol inhibits this critical water-saving mechanism, which can lead to losing too much water and becoming dehydrated.

So, if you're drinking beer, it's a good idea to have a glass of water with every beer to stay hydrated and avoid that dehydrated, hangover feeling!

Alcohol is a diuretic, increasing urine output and potentially causing dehydration

Alcohol is a diuretic, which means it increases urine output. If you’re peeing out more than you’re taking in, this can have a dehydrating effect.

The diuretic effect of alcohol has been recognised since the late sixteenth century, when Shakespeare's Macbeth noted its impact on the porter. Alcohol is one of two diuretic agents commonly found in the modern diet, the other being caffeine.

The extent of the diuresis experienced is thought to be dependent on the amount of alcohol consumed, and its effects on hydration status will be influenced by the concentration of alcohol relative to water in the ingested beverage.

A study published in Nutrients in 2017 found that stronger alcoholic drinks have a short-term diuretic, and therefore potentially dehydrating, effect. The study compared beer (5% ABV), wine (13.5% ABV), spirits (35% ABV) and their non-alcoholic counterparts. It found that urine output after drinking a typical beer was no different from that after a non-alcoholic beer or water. However, AW and S resulted in a higher cumulative urine output compared to NAW and W during the first 4 hours.

Several other studies have drawn similar conclusions: that beer might actually hydrate us adequately. However, the studies do warn that stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating, and that drinks containing essential electrolytes are still better for hydration.

It is widely believed that alcohol exerts its diuretic effect by suppressing a hormone called vasopressin, or ADH. Vasopressin is usually released by the posterior pituitary gland in response to a fall in blood volume or a rise in plasma osmolality, and acts to conserve water. Ingestion of alcohol does increase plasma osmolality, but alcohol also acts directly to inhibit the release of vasopressin, independent of plasma osmolality. However, some studies have questioned whether the effect on vasopressin is solely to blame for the diuretic effect of alcohol.

The bottom line is that alcohol makes you pee more, causing you to lose more water. And this can potentially cause dehydration.

Beer is not all that bad for hydration, especially weak beers

Beer is a diuretic, which means it increases urine output. If you're peeing out more than you're taking in, this can have a dehydrating effect. However, beer might not be all that bad from a hydration perspective.

A study published in The Journal of Applied Physiology explored the hydrating quality of alcohol after exercise-induced dehydration. In the study, 2.2 litres of an alcohol-free beer, along with 1%, 2%, and 4% ABV beer, were consumed. The study suggests that beverages with low alcohol concentrations have "a negligible diuretic effect" when consumed in a state of exercise-induced dehydration, meaning that hydrating with water or a low-alcohol beer (around 2% ABV) is effectively the same. They also found that a 4% ABV beer had the same hydrating qualities but just took longer to achieve the same results.

Another study compared beer (5% ABV), wine (13.5% ABV), spirits (35% ABV) and their non-alcoholic counterparts. It found that the stronger alcoholic drinks have a short-term diuretic and potentially dehydrating effect. Interestingly, they found that urine output after drinking a typical beer was no different from that of a non-alcoholic beer or water. Several other studies have drawn the same conclusion: beer might actually hydrate us adequately! The studies do warn that stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating, and that drinks containing essential electrolytes are still better for hydration. Nevertheless, the evidence points to beer not being all that bad from a hydration perspective.

It's also worth noting that the diuretic action of alcohol is blunted when the body is hypohydrated. A study found that there was no difference in the volume of urine produced between alcohol (4% ABV) and non-alcohol beer when hypohydrated, but there was a difference when euhydrated. This suggests that the diuretic action of alcohol is dependent on the hydration state of the body.

In conclusion, while beer is a diuretic and can increase the risk of dehydration, weak beers with low alcohol content may not be as bad for hydration as previously thought.

Stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating

Alcohol is a diuretic, which means it increases urine output. This can lead to dehydration, especially if you're peeing out more than you're taking in. The amount of alcohol in a drink is thought to determine its diuretic effect, and therefore how much it can dehydrate you.

Most beers have a fairly low ABV (somewhere between 2% and 6%), but some can contain as much as 10% alcohol, similar to most wines. When comparing beer (5% ABV), wine (13.5% ABV), spirits (35% ABV), and their non-alcoholic counterparts, studies have found that stronger alcoholic drinks have a more pronounced short-term diuretic effect and are therefore more likely to be dehydrating. Interestingly, urine output after drinking a typical beer was found to be no different from that of a non-alcoholic beer or water.

Several studies have concluded that beer might actually hydrate us adequately. However, they also warn that stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating. This is because the diuretic effect of alcohol is thought to be dependent on its concentration relative to water in the drink. In other words, the higher the alcohol content, the more likely it is to have a dehydrating effect.

Some brewers are working on making beers that are better for hydration by adding important electrolytes like sodium. Other studies have found that having a beer after proper hydration with water doesn't negatively impact rehydration. While a weak beer will likely do a better job of keeping your hydration levels topped up than drinking higher ABV wine or spirits, nothing beats water (or a drink packed with electrolytes) for hydration.

Beer can be better for hydration when combined with water

Beer is made up of water, barley, hops, and yeast. These natural ingredients are healthy sources of carbohydrates, fat, protein, fiber, vitamins, and minerals. They also contain electrolytes and phyto-nutrients.

Beer has been found to have a negligible diuretic effect when consumed in a state of exercise-induced dehydration. This means that hydrating with water or a low-alcohol beer is effectively the same.

Some studies have found that beer might actually hydrate us adequately. However, stronger beers are likely to be more dehydrating, and drinks containing essential electrolytes are still better for hydration.

Scientists have also tested the effect of having a beer, in addition to proper hydration with water, after exercise. They found that a beer had no negative effects on rehydration.

Therefore, beer can be better for hydration when combined with water.

Frequently asked questions