Singing After Stroke: Unlocking The Mystery Of Lost Speech

why can stroke patients sing but not talk

Aphasia is a language disorder that affects a person's ability to communicate. It is often caused by strokes in the left side of the brain, which control speech and language. While people with aphasia may struggle with daily communication activities, they sometimes retain the ability to sing. This is because the brain uses different networks for processing speech and language than it does for music. The left side of the brain, which is associated with logic and speech, may be damaged by a stroke, while the right side, which is associated with creative skills like music and rhythm, may remain intact. Singing therapy has been shown to be an effective treatment for individuals who have lost the ability to speak after a stroke, as it retrains the undamaged right side of the brain to speak.

Characteristics Values
Phenomenon Stroke patients can sing but not talk
Prevalence Affects about 1/3 of stroke survivors
Cause Damage to parts of the brain that are responsible for language
Condition Aphasia
Aphasia cause Stroke in the left side of the brain
Aphasia symptoms Difficulty with understanding speech, problems with reading and writing, as well as trouble with speaking
Aphasia types Expressive aphasia, fluent aphasia
Treatment Speech therapy, singing therapy, melodic intonation therapy
Singing therapy rationale Singing activates different parts of the brain than speaking
Singing therapy effectiveness Varies, some patients show improvement

medshun

Singing therapy can help stroke patients regain the ability to speak

A stroke occurs when the supply of oxygen-rich blood to the brain is interrupted. When brain cells are deprived of oxygen, they start to sustain damage, and blood flow must be restored as soon as possible to preserve brain tissue. This is why swift stroke treatment is crucial for saving lives and reducing potential disabilities.

About one-third of stroke survivors experience some form of language or communication impairment, known as aphasia. Aphasia affects an individual's ability to communicate, including both written and oral speech skills. It can lead to difficulties in speaking, reading, writing, and comprehension. The condition is caused by damage to the left side of the brain, which is primarily responsible for language processing.

Interestingly, some individuals with aphasia can sing even though they cannot speak. This phenomenon is attributed to the fact that the brain uses different networks for processing speech and language compared to music. Music activates a more extensive area of the brain across both sides, whereas language is predominantly managed on the left side.

Singing therapy, also known as melodic intonation therapy, has emerged as a promising treatment for stroke patients struggling with severe speech difficulties. This approach harnesses the undamaged parts of the brain, particularly the right hemisphere, which is associated with creative skills like music and rhythm. By retraining the brain to use these undamaged regions for speech, individuals can gradually regain their ability to communicate.

The effectiveness of singing therapy is supported by scientific research. A 2008 study compared two patients with similar stroke sizes and locations. The patient who received singing therapy demonstrated greater improvements in speech than the one who underwent conventional treatment. Imaging scans revealed that singing therapy activated the right side of the brain.

Additionally, a study at the Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston, known as the NIH-funded study, is one of the first rigorous trials of singing therapy. The study involves post-stroke patients undergoing either conventional speech therapy or singing therapy for 90 minutes a day, five days a week, for 15 weeks. Initial results suggest that singing therapy can lead to improvements in speech, even enabling patients to speak in single words and short phrases.

The success of singing therapy is attributed to its ability to remold the brain. In the case of Laurel Fontaine, a 16-year-old who suffered a devastating stroke that destroyed 80% of the left side of her brain, singing therapy had permanent effects. While she still struggles to find the right words at times, she doesn't have to sing them out loud anymore. Instead, she sings in her head and talks out loud without singing.

Furthermore, research by Benjamin Stahl and colleagues at the Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences in Leipzig, Germany, revealed that rhythm might be a crucial factor in the success of singing therapy. Their study found that singing was not the decisive factor for improving speech; instead, the positive effect was more significant when patients articulated syllables with rhythmic accompaniment.

Singing therapy not only helps with speech recovery but also has social and emotional benefits. Joining a choir, for instance, can help stroke survivors develop social connections with others who have had similar experiences. It provides a sense of community and support, reducing the feelings of isolation that many aphasia sufferers experience.

While singing therapy may not be comfortable for everyone, it offers a promising avenue for stroke patients to regain their ability to speak and connect with others. Through rigorous and consistent therapy, individuals can retrain their brains to harness undamaged regions for speech production, improving their overall quality of life.

medshun

The brain uses different networks for processing speech and language than it does for music

A stroke occurs when the supply of oxygen-rich blood to the brain is interrupted. Brain cells begin to sustain damage, and blood flow must be restored as soon as possible to preserve brain tissue. Speech therapist and director of the Conservatorium of Newcastle Brainwaves Choir, Bernadette Matthias, explains that the brain manages language predominantly on the left side. In contrast, music activates a large portion of both sides of the brain. This rich interconnection means that even when the language centres of the brain are damaged, the ability to sing often remains.

The right hemisphere of the brain contributes to creative skills such as music and rhythm, while the left hemisphere is responsible for logical skills, including speech. When a stroke impacts the left hemisphere, it can cause difficulties in producing speech. However, the ability to sing is often preserved because it involves the right hemisphere's creative skills.

Research has shown that singing therapy can be an effective treatment for individuals with severe speech difficulties after a stroke. This approach trains the undamaged right side of the brain to "speak" by targeting the region that controls singing. While singing therapy may not be comfortable or accessible for everyone, it has helped many stroke survivors regain their ability to speak.

Additionally, the social aspect of singing in a group can provide significant benefits for stroke survivors, helping them develop social connections and reducing feelings of isolation.

medshun

Stroke survivors may regain their ability to speak due to neuroplasticity

The brain uses different networks for processing speech and language than it does for music. While language is primarily managed on the left side of the brain, music activates a broader network across both hemispheres. This means that stroke survivors may be able to sing even if they cannot speak.

To improve their speech, stroke survivors need to retrain their brains to control speech-associated skills. This involves rigorous and consistent therapy, such as speech therapy, to practice speaking by repeating single words. The high repetition of these tasks helps to strengthen the neural pathways involved in speech production.

Neuroplasticity is most active in the first six months after a stroke, so rehabilitation should begin as soon as possible to maximize recovery. During this period, survivors are likely to experience the fastest and most significant improvements in function.

In addition to speech therapy, singing therapy can also be a promising treatment for individuals who cannot speak after a stroke. Singing is a creative skill that involves rhythm and music, which are often controlled by the right hemisphere of the brain. An experienced speech therapist can help survivors sing short phrases and eventually work up to saying those phrases, gradually regaining some speech abilities.

medshun

Aphasia is a language disorder that affects your ability to communicate

There are two broad categories of aphasia: fluent and non-fluent, with several types falling within these groups. For example, people with Wernicke's aphasia, the most common type of fluent aphasia, may speak in long, complete sentences that are nonsensical, adding unnecessary words and even creating made-up words. On the other hand, people with Broca's aphasia, the most common type of non-fluent aphasia, may understand speech and know what they want to say, but they often speak in short phrases that are produced with great effort, omitting small words such as "is", "and", and "the".

The effects of aphasia can vary depending on the area and extent of the damage to the brain. Some people with aphasia may have trouble with expressive language, or the ability to produce speech, while others may have difficulty with receptive language, or the ability to understand what is being said. Some may experience a combination of both expressive and receptive aphasia.

While aphasia can be a frustrating and isolating condition, there are treatments available that can help improve communication skills. Speech-language therapy is often used to help patients regain their ability to communicate, and new technologies such as virtual speech pathologists and speech-generating applications on mobile devices can provide alternative ways to communicate. Group therapy and activities such as book clubs and art groups can also help improve communication skills and build confidence.

Foot Drop: A Common Ailment Post-Stroke

You may want to see also

medshun

Melodic intonation therapy can help bridge the gap between singing and speaking

Melodic Intonation Therapy (MIT) is a well-known singing-based therapy used to treat patients with severe language impairment, such as aphasia, after a stroke. MIT uses the musical elements of speech, such as melody and rhythm, to improve expressive language. This therapy takes advantage of the patient's preserved ability to sing and engages language-capable regions in the undamaged right hemisphere of the brain.

MIT was introduced in 1973 and has since been modified extensively by clinicians and researchers worldwide. The key features of MIT include intoning (singing) common phrases slowly and tapping the left hand, following a hierarchy of steps that eventually moves from singing to speech. MIT is typically recommended for patients with Broca's aphasia, who have non-fluent speech and relatively good auditory comprehension.

The effectiveness of MIT is thought to be due to several mechanisms that work together to improve language function. Firstly, MIT may promote neuroplastic reorganization of the language network in the brain. It is believed that MIT activates the right hemisphere, which is typically involved in music processing, to compensate for damage in the left hemisphere, which is dominant for language. This activation of the right hemisphere may facilitate language recovery and improve language production.

Secondly, MIT is a multimodal therapy that provides patients with an auditory and visual model to observe, imitate, and synchronize. The left-hand tapping component of MIT is thought to engage a right sensorimotor integration network, linking hand and articulatory movements. This may improve articulatory motor function and facilitate speech production.

Thirdly, MIT utilizes shared features of music and language, such as pitch and rhythm, to access language indirectly through music processing pathways. Singing is typically more right-lateralized in the brain, while speaking is more left-lateralized. By tapping into the right hemisphere's music processing regions, MIT may help patients with left-hemisphere lesions to regain language function.

Finally, MIT may improve mood and motivation in patients with aphasia, making it a pleasurable and non-threatening form of therapy. Music is known to activate the brain's reward and motivation circuitry, releasing neurotransmitters associated with pleasure and motivation. This can enhance patients' motivation to continue with intensive therapy regimens and positively impact their overall mood.

In conclusion, MIT is a promising treatment for stroke patients with severe language impairment. By combining singing with specific therapeutic techniques, MIT helps bridge the gap between singing and speaking. The effectiveness of MIT is likely due to a combination of neurobiological, cognitive, and emotional mechanisms that synergistically improve language function and promote recovery.

Frequently asked questions

A stroke occurs when the supply of oxygen-rich blood to the brain is interrupted. If the left side of the brain is affected, the language centres of the brain that control speech and language can be damaged, resulting in a condition called aphasia. However, the right side of the brain, which is associated with creative skills like music and rhythm, may remain intact, allowing some stroke patients to sing even when they cannot speak.

Singing therapy, also known as melodic intonation therapy, is a treatment method that harnesses the power of neuroplasticity, or the brain's ability to create and strengthen new neural connections. By retraining the undamaged parts of the brain to "speak", stroke patients can gradually regain their ability to communicate. Additionally, singing therapy can improve mood and social participation, reducing the sense of isolation that many stroke survivors experience.

Here are some strategies to support communication with a stroke patient:

- Practice patience and positivity: Encourage your loved one to keep trying and provide a supportive environment for them to practice their communication skills.

- Minimise distractions: Turn off the TV, avoid noisy areas, and ensure you are facing the person when speaking to minimise distractions and help them focus on the conversation.

- Use clear and simple communication: Introduce the topic, ask yes or no questions, and summarise what has been discussed. Speak in a normal tone and volume, assuming they can hear and understand unless indicated otherwise.

- Explore alternative communication methods: Writing pads, cue cards, pictures, gestures, and computer programs can all facilitate communication when speaking is challenging.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment